Skip to the content
The Ocean of the Quran

Yūsuf 12:74

قَالُوا۟ فَمَا جَزَٰٓؤُهُۥٓ إِن كُنتُمْ كَٰذِبِينَ 

They said: ‘What shall be its requital if you [prove to] be lying?’

BookmarkHighlightNote

Exegesis

The pronoun suffix hu in jazāʾuhu (its requital) could be understood as referring to the goblet, meaning: what shall be the requital of stealing it.1 Alternatively, hu could be translated as ‘his’, meaning: what shall be his (the thief’s) requital for stealing it.2 A third suggestion is that hu is referring to the act of theft, meaning: what is the requital of theft.3 This latter option seems more attractive.

Exposition

They said: ‘What shall be its requital if you [prove to] be lying?’: it is only reasonable to assume the servants of Prophet Joseph (a) were instructed by him to say this. Their question was: if after investigation evidence shows that you were actually the thieves, then what shall be the requital?4 The purpose of saying this was to extract from them a statement of consent to a punishment before the guilt was established – at a time that they were confident their innocence would be proven. This tactic served two purposes: it created irreversible consent to justice, eliminating room for protest, and more crucially, it ensured the thief would face justice according to the laws of Canaan (and not Egypt) – as agreed by them – since Egyptian law prescribed a different penalty for theft, and Prophet Joseph (a) had no legal grounds to detain Benjamin under Egyptian law for this alleged crime.

Footnotes · 4

  1. 1

    Zamakhshari, 2/490.

    ↩︎
  2. 2

    Qurtubi, 9/234.

    ↩︎
  3. 3

    Mizan, 11/224.

    ↩︎
  4. 4

    Tibyan, 6/172.

    ↩︎